At FIA Expo in Chicago on 4 November, congressional staff and senior executives from Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley discussed how the shift in control of Congress could reshape derivatives policy in 2027, from oversight and leadership of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to digital asset legislation and efforts to harmonise regulation between the CFTC and the Securities and Exchange Commission.
The changing political landscape also raises questions about the future of digital asset market structure legislation, particularly efforts to establish federal oversight of spot markets. Earlier this year, the Clarity Act failed to pass a procedural vote in the Senate despite more than a year of negotiations. Now that Democrats are slated to take control of both chambers of Congress, the process will have to start anew next year.
Ogilvie noted that 78 House Democrats supported the Clarity Act, and said this demonstrated significant bipartisan backing for greater regulatory certainty, even though some had wanted additional customer protections and other safeguards.
He said future legislation covering the CFTC's role could build on previous work, potentially drawing on a compromise discussion draft developed by the Senate Agriculture Committee in a previous Congress.
Ogilvie also raised the possibility that the CFTC-related provisions could advance separately if lawmakers could not reach agreement on the securities side.
Reaching agreement over the treatment of digital assets under securities law could prove considerably harder, Anonick agreed. He recalled disagreements among Senate Democrats over whether most digital assets should be considered commodities, a distinction with implications for the respective roles of the CFTC and SEC. “There was not a consensus that most of these assets are commodities,” he said.
Anonick was also sceptical that Senate Democrats would support legislation that addressed only the CFTC's jurisdiction. Nevertheless, he said the gap in federal oversight of digital asset spot markets remained and would continue to require attention.
Ryan Jachym, managing director at Goldman Sachs, said the CFTC and the SEC were making use of their existing authority to address digital assets, but warned that some regulatory measures without statutory backing might prove less durable.
She said both agencies appeared to recognise that risk and were increasingly seeking industry input through advance notices of proposed rulemaking and requests for comment before developing formal proposals. “If it is good policy then the likelihood that it is not durable is lower,” she said.
Prediction markets have emerged as another significant issue for the next Congress, with lawmakers approaching the issue from several directions.
Ogilvie said some members were focused on sports-related contracts and possible protections addressing children's safety and mental health, while others had raised questions about election markets and contracts involving war or military actions.
“There are a lot of different priorities that people have in this area and over time we are going to have to figure out where the consensus is,” he said.
Anonick described prediction markets as one of the most complex issues he had encountered, pointing to competing interests involving the industry, tribes, casinos and sports leagues, alongside concerns about insider trading, sensitive event contracts and markets based on economic indicators.
He said legislative reform might not be politically possible in the next two years. Any legislation amending the Commodity Exchange Act would go through the Agriculture Committee on the Senate side, he said, although the wider debate would likely involve other Senate committees, including Banking and Indian Affairs.
Jennifer Jacoby, executive director at Morgan Stanley, said the future treatment of prediction markets was likely to emerge from a combination of congressional action, CFTC decisions and court rulings.
She pointed to unresolved legal questions surrounding federal pre-emption of state law and tribal gaming regulation. She added that, if the Supreme Court takes up the issue, it could address some of those questions as early as late 2027, although she cautioned that the timing could slip.
Despite the broader disagreements, the panellists identified narrower measures that could attract bipartisan support.
Ogilvie suggested restrictions on members of Congress trading on prediction markets or contracts tied to US military operations. Jachym said Congress might tackle prediction markets in “bite-sized pieces”, potentially through amendments attached to must-pass legislation.
For Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley, the political changes in Washington are unlikely to alter their fundamental approach to regulatory policy.
Both executives emphasised the importance of bipartisan policymaking, while Jachym noted that regulatory initiatives can extend across political cycles.
Jachym identified the Basel III endgame capital framework as one of the most significant regulatory issues for Goldman Sachs, saying bank capital requirements have a significant bearing on its ability to participate in markets and serve clients. She said the treatment of client clearing had been a particularly important part of that debate.
Jacoby said Basel III and capital requirements for global systemically important banks were similarly important for Morgan Stanley.
Both also highlighted the need for continued harmonisation between the SEC and CFTC.
Jachym said closer coordination would benefit firms operating under multiple registrations across the two agencies, particularly as new products and technologies emerge. Clarifying the requirements facing dual registrants would be “tremendously helpful”, she said.
Jacoby called for continued industry engagement and refinement of extraterritorial rules that could affect US firms' ability to compete in global markets.
Looking ahead, Jachym said regulatory initiatives already under way would remain important regardless of the changes in Congress, noting that four years can be a short period in the regulatory process.
“It's generally pretty hard to get anything done that's not bipartisan,” Jachym said.